What Is Purgatory and Is it in the Bible?

Upon dying, does the human soul really travel to a temporary place to purify itself? Can the soul “cleanse” itself before entering the fullness of Heaven? Whether you believe in purgatory or not, this historical doctrine regarding its existence is intriguing.

Purgatory is integral to the Roman Catholic faith, but what does the Bible say about it? And how can Protestant Christians lovingly engage with Catholics beyond just an intellectual understanding of the doctrine? Let’s explore this how this idea is understood today as well as what famous theologians like Augustine and Martin Luther thought about it.

Photo Credit: Unsplash

Purgatory: What is it?

Purgatory: What is it?

According to Dictionary.com, purgatory is “a condition or place in which the souls of those dying…are purified…from sins.” Essentially, purgatory is part of the Catholic doctrine of faith where a “final purification” occurs in order to “achieve the holiness necessary to enter…heaven,” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, CCC 1030-31).

The famous theologian Augustine – considered a founding father of Christianity – advocated  praying for the dead. He felt prayer removed the final traces of sin after a human passed away. According to Catholic Online, St. Augustine lead a life of drinking and sexual immorality. Could Augustine’s inner-guilt from his personal experiences with sin lead him to embrace the idea of purgatory? Perhaps so.

Photo Credit: WikiMedia

The Council of Trent

The Council of Trent

In 1545, in response to Martin Luther and his Protestant Reformation, the Catholic Church established a commission to assess the deep levels of corruptions including the selling of indulgences and bribery. During this time, the Council of Trent reaffirmed the doctrine of purgatory.

The Gospel Coalition reported on 450th anniversary of the Council of Trent in their article, “9 Things You Should Know About the Council of Trent.”

“Under Catholic teaching, every sin must be purified either here on earth or after death in a state called purgatory…The council affirmed the doctrine of purgatory and damned anyone who claimed, ‘that after the grace of justification has been received the guilt is so remitted and the debt of eternal punishment so blotted out for any repentant sinner, that no debt of temporal punishment remains to be paid,’” The Gospel Coalition reported.

Photo Credit: WikiMedia

Does Scripture Support Purgatory?

Does Scripture Support Purgatory?

The very popular Pope John Paul II, with the support of the Italian Vatican, published a second edition of the Catechism of the Catholic Church in 1997. It states, praying for the dead was necessary:

All who die in God’s grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation; but after death they undergo purification, so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven. (CCC 1030).

Devout Catholics also look to the book of 1 Corinthians to support their beliefs about purgatory.

If anyone’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but only as through fire,” (I Cor. 3:15).

Nick Rabiipour, reporter for Get Fed, believes purgatory is essential. “Many Christians die with attachments to sin that must be gotten rid of before they can be united with God in a perfect union of love through all eternity,” he wrote in his article, What Do Catholics Really Believe About Purgatory?

Photo Credit: Thinkstock

What Did Jesus Say About Purgatory?

What Did Jesus Say About Purgatory?

Jesus mentioned nothing about the existence of purgatory. If anything, Jesus spoke more about the realities of hell than the doctrine of purgatory.

During his crucifixion, Jesus offered a profound answer to a dying thief.

Then he said, ‘Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom.’ Jesus answered him, ‘Truly I tell you, today you will be with me in paradise,’” Luke 23:42-43.

Jesus is Author and Finisher of our faith. Jesus’s words are true. If He said, “today,” than he meant it.

In Matthew 13:49, Jesus spoke of what would come at the end of the Church Age – that angels would separate an evil humanity from a righteous one. Matthew 13:50 goes on to tell us the wicked would be thrown into a fiery furnace where weeping and gnashing of teeth would occur. This scripture does not support the doctrine of purgatory.

Photo Credit: Thinkstock

The Refiner’s Fire Occurs Here on Earth

The Refiner’s Fire Occurs Here on Earth

Malachi 3:3 states, “He will sit as a refiner and purifier of silver, and he will purify the sons of Levi and refine them like gold and silver and they will bring offerings in righteousness to the Lord.”

For contextual purposes, Bible readers must consider what is written in the prior verse, “But who can endure the day of His coming? And who can stand when He appears?” Malachi 3:2.

Every waking day of a Christ-follower’s life is a day for Christ to spiritually refine us. Spiritual refinement is a lifelong process which occurs while we live and breathe on earth.

Photo Credit: Unsplash

Challenging circumstances refine and purify us.

Challenging circumstances refine and purify us.

Consider it pure joy, my brothers and sisters, whenever you face trials of many kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance. Let perseverance finish its work so that you may be mature and complete, not lacking anything,” James 1:2-4.

As the Holy Spirit prompts questions like these in your heart, think of them as refining trials, and “consider it pure joy.”

●       Could I have responded in a gentler manner?

●       Did I serve others without complaint?

●       Has bitterness caused me to harbor resentment towards others?

●       Am I judging the walk of a recent convert?

●       Do I show the love of Christ to others?

“Fires” will come to every believer because this life doesn’t absolve us of difficulties. Challenging circumstances refine and purify us.

Photo Credit: Unsplash

How Should I Respond to Catholics?

How Should I Respond to Catholics?

Let’s review the scripture which Catholics use to support purgatory:

“If it is burned up, the builder will suffer loss but yet will be saved – even though only as one escaping through the flames,” 1 Corinthians 3:15.

It is critical to look at this scripture in context. Apostle Paul, using an analogy, wrote that believers are “builders” whose foundation is Christ:

Their work will be shown for what it is, because the Day will bring it to light. It will be revealed with fire, and the fire will test the quality of each person’s work,” 1 Corinthians 3:13-14.

Upon death, one does not work. If purgatory does exist, what kind of “work” is done?

Photo Credit: Pexels

We are living testimonies.

We are living testimonies.

While we are alive, we are living testimonies. We are God’s workmanship. Are we showing others the love of God? Are we living in such a manner that compels others to ask, “Why are you so happy? Why are you so positive?”

It is Christ in us which will convince the lost. This is how we “build” the Kingdom of God.

It probably isn’t the best witness to yell or ridicule the beliefs of devout Catholics. Instead, let’s focus on four things that Protestants and Catholics have in common:

1. We believe that Christ died for the sins of humanity.

2. We believe that grace alone saves us.

3. We believe he rose again.

4. We believe that he will one day return to reclaim us.

Apostle Paul encouraged the Body of Christ with these words, “Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in love. Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace,” Ephesians 4:2-3.

Photo Credit: Unsplash

Timothy Paul Jones on Purgatory:

Timothy Paul Jones on Purgatory:

Timothy Paul Jones, author and associate vice present at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, talks about purgatory in his Crosswalk.com video, “Does the Bible Support the Idea That Purgatory Exists?

“Really what we’re dealing with in the question of purgatory is: How does a Christian enter God’s presence – God’s holy presence – when there is still sin unconfessed in his or her life? That’s really what we’re asking.”

Jones discusses the theological idea from the perspective of Augustine in the 5th century, Martin Luther in the 16th century, and modern Roman Catholic thinking on the issue.

“The same problem remains with purgatory. It’s requiring something other than – more than – the finished work of Jesus on the cross to make us right with God,” he said.

Photo Credit: Unsplash

More from Crosswalk.com on Purgatory:

More from Crosswalk.com on Purgatory:

Jessica Galán encourages her readers to embrace malleability in the midst of life’s difficult moments. She spends her day teaching amazing students from diverse backgrounds in Fairfield County, Connecticut. She’s wife to a super-creative man and the proud mother of three resilient young women. She’s served as a writing facilitator for Lysa TerKeurst through COMPEL Training. She enjoys daily cups of steaming hot café con leche and breaks out in sporadic salsa dancing when no one’s looking. You’ll find her stories at jessicagalan.net. Connect with her here: Twitter || Instagram ||Facebook

For more insight on purgatory and other common misconceptions of what happens afer death, read, “Does the Bible Say What Happens After Death?

Photo Credit: Unsplash

 


This article is part of our larger End Times Resource Library. Learn more about the rapture, the anti-christ, bible prophecy and the tribulation with articles that explain Biblical truths. You do not need to fear or worry about the future!

Four Keys

Today’s Bible ReadingDeuteronomy 29:1–29

Recommended ReadingDeuteronomy 5Hebrews 121 John 2:16–17

In the late 1980s Stephen Covey created a stir when he wrote The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. The book, which has sold more than 10 million copies and has spawned a cottage industry of business seminars and organizational tools, lists seven principles for success in both personal and professional life.

Thousands of years ago, Moses paused at the end of his life to speak to the Israelites. He reminded them of who they were, of all that they’d come through, to whom they belonged and how they could continue living as the people of God. While he delivered this speech to the people of ancient Israel, Moses’ words provide four keys to success for Christians today:

1. Remember. Moses reminded the Israelites of the miracles they had witnessed and the trials they had endured in the wilderness. He pointed out that their clothes and sandals had miraculously held up for 40 years—a very practical example of God’s care and provision.

We can all point to times in our lives when God has met an important need. Remembering God’s expressions of love and care helps bolster our faith and courage. And we can view challenges through the lens of experience, knowing that God will continue to provide and care for us.

2. Obey. Moses urged the people to follow the terms of God’s covenant with them. By following God’s commands they would enjoy God’s partnership. Disobedience would bring suffering and failure in the new land.

God still calls us to obedience—to avoiding sin and striving toward holiness. Living this way will yield positive results in our lives now and for eternity, even when our circumstances are difficult or painful.

3. Focus. Moses knew that the Israelites would encounter many intriguing cultures and would be tempted to fall into the practices and customs of their neighbors. They were to keep their focus on God rather than being enticed by paganism and idolatry.

We too can easily get caught up in behaviors and thinking contrary to God’s plan for our lives. God doesn’t ask us to be tolerant and inclusive. Instead, he commands us to be discerning, filled with his Spirit and focused on him.

4. Recall. Moses encouraged the Israelites to hold on to what they knew about God—all that God had revealed to them.

As we celebrate the ways God works in our lives, as we walk in obedience to his Word and as we keep our eyes off the world and on him, God will reveal to us more and more of himself and his wonders.

To Take Away

  • How can remembering what God has done in your past make it easier for you to endure new challenges?
  • What “idols” entice you to remove your focus from God?
  • When you pray, ask God to reveal himself to you in new ways in the next few months.

Copyright © 2006 by Zondervan.

INSTITUTE FOR CREATION RESEARCH

N

  The Tongue of the Learned
“The Lord GOD hath given me the tongue of the learned, that I should know how to speak a word in season to him that is weary: he wakeneth morning by morning, he wakeneth mine ear to hear as the learned.” (Isaiah 50:4)

The prophetic words of our text were spoken by the Lord Jesus in the context of His suffering: “I gave my back to the smiters…I hid not my face from shame and spitting” (v. 6)—and His attentiveness to the will of His Father despite the suffering —“The Lord GOD hath opened mine ear, and I was not rebellious, neither turned away back” (v. 5). The amazing love of Christ is seen in the fact that, in the midst of His intense personal pain, He could still continue, even on the cross, “to speak a word in season to him that is weary,” as He comforted His mother, spoke salvation to the dying thief, and even sought forgiveness for His executioners.

In all this, He was “leaving us an example, that ye should follow his steps” (1 Peter 2:21). How easy and natural it is to complain and rebel when we are suffering. We seek comfort and counsel from others, when we (like our Exemplar) should be comforting others with “the comfort wherewith we ourselves are comforted of God” (2 Corinthians 1:4).

Though we cannot comprehend it fully, we must simply believe the mystery of the incarnation. God became man in Jesus Christ, and the omnipotent One “learned…obedience” (Hebrews 5:8). He was omniscient, yet somehow He “increased in wisdom” (Luke 2:52), as well as stature, and as He studied God’s Word, wakening “morning by morning,” He learned to hear the voice of the Father, thus receiving “the tongue of the learned,” that “gracious words” might proceed out of His mouth (Luke 4:22).

May the Lord grant each of His younger sons and daughters this gracious “tongue of the learned,” as we, like His Firstborn, awaken each morning to hear His voice. HMM

 

Grace Upon Grace

 

Anchor

This content is drawn from: Psalm 103:1-22

“For from his fullness we have all received, grace upon grace.” John 1:16 (ESV)

Grace highlights our relationship with God. In the midst of our continual shortcomings, weaknesses, fears, and bondage to sin, the gospel of grace teaches us that God not only gives us grace but gives us Himself in grace by His Son and through His Spirit. God is constantly showering us with underserved favor for Jesus’ sake.

The comforting words of Psalm 103 remind us that “the Lord is compassionate and gracious” (v. 8). Because of God’s simplicity (turn back to Days 2 and 3), we are reminded that grace and graciousness are the hallmarks of our God. There is no hidden corner of God that is ungracious. Therefore, “he does not treat us as our sins deserve” (v. 10). Furthermore, we see the relationship between His omniscience and graciousness in which He knows our weakness but is not surprised by it (v. 13-16).

Peter was no doubt surprised by his own unfaithfulness when he denied Jesus (Luke 22:31-34; 54-62). Yet Jesus, being full of grace, already knew He would restore Peter fully (v. 32). That’s grace upon grace!

INSIGHT

In what ways are you particularly in need of God’s grace today? Know that He gives Himself to you in your sin and confusion.

 
 

My Conversation with a Hedge – Crosswalk the Devotional – May 16

My Conversation with a Hedge
by Shawn McEvoy

He who neglects discipline despises himself, But he who listens to reproof acquires understanding. The fear of the LORD is the instruction for wisdom, And before honor comes humility. – Proverbs 15:32

Some years during summer, my wife and kids leave me for two-to-three weeks to visit all of her relatives in Texas while I stay home and work. For the first day or two that they’re gone, I enjoy my freedom from some of my responsibilities. After that, though, I tend to go a little crazy. I find myself wandering around the house, or doing “improvement” projects I have no business tackling. Making up song lyrics. Or having conversations with inanimate objects.

A couple years ago, in the middle of their trip, I was trimming the bushes beneath our front windows. The three on the right side of the stoop grow more uniformly than the three on the left. On the left, the one closest to the stairs is healthiest, while the other two, thanks to heavier afternoon shade, don’t do as well. Oh, it’s hard to tell, because I keep them pruned so that they “grow together” in the middle and stay squared off on the tops and corners. But obviously, the two weaker bushes suffer the pruning less frequently, because I let them grow out to fill in the gaps.

As I was working, their healthier sibling, I imagined, began to speak to me. Or to whine is more like it…

Hey! What gives?

Nothing, my good man. Just time for your monthly trimming.

But why? I’m not doing anything wrong. Just sitting here minding my own business. Doing good, doing what I’m supposed to do. And here you come…

Well, just sit still, please. Trust me, I have a purpose here.

Really? Well forgive me for asking, but why doesn’t that purpose seem to apply to my lazy, stunted brethren here? All this time and barely a scratch. Maybe a nip, a cut. Nothing lost, no pain.

You’re not happy with how you look? Where you’re situated?

I’m fine. But that’s just it. I don’t deserve this cutting and trimming.

You think you planted yourself in this primo spot?

Never really thought about it. I just want to know why you’re taking so much away from me and nothing from them.

I told you I have a purpose. You can’t see what I can see. In fact, you can’t see much at all. You’re completely rooted in place. But I’ve seen all around you and through you, and have since you were planted.

But it hurts. I don’t like losing things.

Never having them in the first place, and never really growing, that’s not much good either. I have to give extra care and attention to those others. I can only hope it brings them up to the same level of maturity as you…

Hmmph.

I finished trimming up the hedges, and went my way, unsure I had gotten through. But when I stood back, I beheld something beautiful. I could only hope those under my care understood, had not despised their discipline, and opted to forsake impractical, joyless comparison.

Intersecting Faith & Life: The next time you feel like others aren’t being as challenged as you are, or like the Lord is picking on you unfairly, consider that you can’t see all the perspectives or purposes of the Lord, not in your life and especially not in the lives of others. The Lord loves you enough to discipline you, and he knows you’re healthy and with enough green growth to handle His pruning.

Further Reading

John 15:1
Pruning Your Vineyard

Check out fantastic resources on FaithFamily, and Fun at Crosswalk.com!

No Junk Allowed

NIGHT LIKE FOR COUPLES

“Man looks at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart.” 1 Samuel 16:7

Seven‐year‐old Chris Krebs was born with cerebral palsy and was profoundly retarded. One day he and his father, Greg, sat in a hospital lounge waiting for Mrs. Krebs, who worked at the hospital. Another man, shabbily dressed and emanating a peculiar aroma, was also waiting there. He looked like a bum or derelict. Greg went to the nurses’ station and asked how much longer his wife would be. When he returned, he saw Chris sitting by the man. The man was sobbing, and Greg wondered what Chris had done to disturb him.

“I’m sorry if my son offended you,” Greg said.

The man replied, “Offended me? Your son is the only person who has hugged me in the last twenty years!” Greg later said, “I realized at that moment Chris had a more Christ-like love for this man than I did.”

Although disrespect for the disabled or less fortunate is characteristic of our culture, we know there is no “junk” in God’s value system. He loves every one of us the same. He sees our potential, and He uses each person to accomplish some part of His purpose. As His children, we’re called to look at everyone through the lens of His perfect love.

When we show compassion and respect to the people who cross our paths from day to day, we are also likely to treat our spouse the same way. It all begins with a spirit of loving‐kindness.

Just between us…

  • Has anyone ever unexpectedly modeled Christ’s love to you?
  • How can we encourage each other to see value and potential in everyone we meet?

Father, may we always be sensitive to the needs and value of other people. Help us to share Your love to them, no matter who they are. Amen.

  • From Night Light For Couples, by Dr. James & Shirley Dobson
    Copyright © 2000 by James Dobson, Inc. All rights reserved.

Character Vacation

 

NIGHT LIKE FOR PARENTS

Whatever happens, conduct yourselves in a manner worthy of the gospel of Christ. Philippians 1:27

It’s easy for moms and dads to come up with reasons for taking a “character vacation.” You may think, for instance, Everyone else cheats on their taxes, so why shouldn’t I? Or, No one will care if I take a few things from the office (or factory) to use at home. But once you start your slide into the pit of rationalization, it’s very difficult to climb back out—and equally tough to keep your children from joining you.

In the first days of the Christian church, a man named Ananias and his wife, Sapphira, thought they could fool God by appearing to be generous. First they sold a piece of property. Then Ananias, with his wife’s knowledge, kept some of the money and presented the rest to the apostles, pretending that it was the full amount from the sale. Peter confronted him: “What made you think of doing such a thing? You have not lied to men but to God.” Ananias immediately fell down and died. When Sapphira arrived later, also pretending that they had given the full amount, she too died at Peter’s feet (Acts 5:1–10).

Our kids are watching our character closely. God is watching, too. He knows when our actions are forthright and when we distort the truth: “The integrity of the upright guides them, but the unfaithful are destroyed by their duplicity” (Proverbs 11:3). We must remember—and teach our children—that God’s desire for us is to keep our character intact.

Before you say good night…

Are there times when you take a “character vacation”?

Are you modeling godly character to your children?

Gracious Lord, we too often allow troubles and our own priorities to pull us away from You. Let us cling to You and Your eternal Word, no matter what the circumstances. Build our trust as we stay ever faithful to You. Amen.

  • From Night Light For Parents, by Dr. James & Shirley Dobson
    Copyright © 2000 by James Dobson, Inc. All rights reserved.